🍦 Nearly 40 flavors in the dipping cabinet🎂 Custom ice cream cakes — 2 days' notice🍭 Candy wall from lollipops to chocolate bars⭐ Five Star Rewards — ask Mark to sign up📍 3431-F Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH

Home · Party Favors

Party Favors

We'd love to help customize your event with our party favors. All special order items require a two day notice and 50% deposit at the time of the order.

See what we make How to order
Give us a couple of days All special order items require a two day notice and a 50% deposit at the time of the order. Big candy bucket orders may need up to six days — the more you want, the more heads-up helps.
Made to order

Our party favors

1
An ice cream pie with a cookie crumb top, ringed with piped whipped topping

Ice Cream Pies

Graham cracker crust with choice of two ice creams — topping or cookies or nuts or candy can be added.

2
A clown face treat: ice cream on a cookie with an upturned cone hat, red nose and blue icing eyes

Clown Faces

Small dip of ice cream on an Oreo cookie, small cone, decorated with icing.

3
A party person treat on a cookie base, decorated with pink icing hair, candy sunglasses and a smile

Party People

Small dip of ice cream on an Oreo cookie decorated with candy and icing.

4
Two party dips in paper cupcake liners — one rainbow-swirled, one cookies and cream

Party Dips

Ice cream in cupcake paper — ready to serve, no dipping.

5
Two party cones dipped in chocolate — one rolled in rainbow sprinkles, one in chopped nuts

Party Cones

Your choice of ice cream — dipped in chocolate, rolled in nuts or sprinkles.

6
Candy buckets wrapped in cellophane and tied with ribbon, surrounded by loose wrapped candy

Candy Buckets

Plastic container filled with candy and wrapped in cellophane with ribbons. We have about 20 different designs of cellophane — come into the store to see the designs!

See notice periods below

How it works

Ordering

All special order items require a two day notice and 50% deposit at the time of the order.

Please allow us lead time to make them for you — 2 to 5 days. Come in today to place your order and your deposit.

Call the shop Find us

Candy bucket notice

Notice required depends on how many buckets you need.

Up to 20 buckets2 days
21 – 50 buckets3 days
51 – 75 buckets4 days
76 – 100 buckets5 days
101 and up6 days
Also available

Custom cakes

Customize a cake for your special occasion. Yellow or chocolate cake, your choice of up to two ice cream flavors, and a message on top.

Build a custom cake Stock up on candy
A plate of fresh cookies in the shop display case — snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, peanut butter blossom and more
Fresh from the case